The Last Vampire of New England

Hey Coastal,

The men came for her in the morning.

They walked into the little graveyard behind the Baptist church. Some carried shovels, for the two graves that would have to be dug. Nobody said much. Across the cemetery sat a squat stone crypt, and inside it, waiting for the ground to thaw, was a 19-year-old girl who had been dead for two months.

They weren't there to mourn her.

They were there to find out if she was still feeding.

It started with the mother.

In 1883, Mary Eliza Brown began to waste away in her farmhouse in Exeter, Rhode Island. She grew pale. She grew thin. She coughed through the nights, and there was blood. By December, she was dead.

Seven months later, her oldest daughter, Mary Olive, started coughing too. Same pale skin. Same sleepless nights. Same blood. She was 20 years old when they buried her next to her mother.

The doctors called it consumption. But the neighbors had another word for it, an old one, the kind people in that part of New England only said in low voices.

Because this is what it looked like: something was coming for the Browns at night. Something that drained them, one by one, until there was nothing left.

And it wasn't done.

Years passed. Then George Brown's only son, Eddie, a big, strong young man with a new wife and his whole life ahead of him, started to cough.

His family sent him west to Colorado, to the dry mountain air, praying it would save him. For a while, it seemed to.

Then his little sister got sick.

Her name was Mercy Lena Brown. Everyone called her Lena. She was 19, and what she caught was the worst kind, the kind people called “galloping” consumption, because it ran you down so fast. The doctor told her father there was nothing left to try.

In January 1892, Lena died.

The ground was frozen too hard to dig a grave. So, most likely, they carried her across the cemetery and laid her in the cold stone crypt to wait for spring.

Five weeks later, Eddie stepped off a train back in Rhode Island. Colorado hadn't saved him. He'd come home to die.

And that's when the whispering started.

Eddie was fading fast now. Some say he was tormented by fever dreams, and that in them, his dead sister came to his bedside and called for him to come with her.

Whether he dreamed it or not, the neighbors had already decided. One of the dead Brown women wasn't really dead. One of them was still feeding, slipping out of the grave each night and draining the life from her brother, the way she must have drained the others.

And there was only one way to stop it.

You open the graves. You find the one that hasn't rotted the way the dead are supposed to. And you take out her heart.

George Brown didn't believe a word of it. But his neighbors were terrified. They'd watched this thing move from house to house. They had children of their own. The Providence Journal later said George was “besieged on all sides.”

So the grieving father, who had already buried his wife and two daughters, gave in. He let them do it, just to “satisfy the neighbors.”

He didn't come to watch.

March 17, 1892. The men, the local doctor, and one newspaper reporter stood among the stones.

They dug up the mother first. Eight years in the ground. What was left of her was dried and shrunken, and there was no blood in her heart. Not her.

They dug up Mary Olive. She was nothing but bones and a long tangle of hair. Not her either.

Then they walked across the cemetery to the crypt. For Lena, they didn't need shovels. They only needed to open the door.

They opened Lena's coffin. And there she was.

Two months dead, and she barely looked it. The reporter wrote that she was “in a fairly well preserved state.” Not gray. Not rotting. To the men leaning over her, she looked like a girl who might open her eyes.

There's an old family story that says something even worse. That when they opened the coffin, Lena wasn't lying the way they'd left her. That she had turned over.

The doctor did what they'd brought him there to do. He cut her open, and he took out her heart.

There was blood in it.

That was all the proof they needed.

They carried Lena's heart and liver to a rock at the edge of the graveyard, built a fire on top of it, and burned them until nothing was left but ash. The reporter noted that when it was over, the men “seemed satisfied.”

But the cure wasn't finished.

They gathered the ashes. They mixed them into a drink. And they brought it to Eddie, who was dying.

He drank his sister's heart.

Two months later, Eddie Brown was dead.

Here's the part that makes it worse.

The doctor standing in that cemetery knew exactly what he was looking at. Blood in the heart of a body kept two months in a freezing crypt was normal, he told them. And when he looked in Lena's lungs, he found what had really killed her, and her mother, and her sister, and was killing her brother: tuberculosis.

The truth was right there in his hands. Nobody wanted it.

Two days later, the Providence Journal ran the whole thing under the headline: “Exhumed the Bodies: Testing a Horrible Superstition in the Town of Exeter.”

And Lena Brown might have stayed a strange local news story forever, if not for one man who read about her.

A few years later, a clipping about the case turned up among the papers of a theater manager and writer in London.

His name was Bram Stoker.

In 1897, Stoker published Dracula. And in it is a young woman named Lucy, who grows pale and weak, night after night, as something drains her. Who dies. Whose tomb is opened under a doctor's eye. And who is found lying there, not decayed at all.

Many people believe Lucy is Lena.

You can visit her. Behind the little white church on Ten Rod Road in Exeter, about halfway down the path, under an evergreen tree.

Her headstone is chained to the ground with an iron strap, because people keep trying to steal it. Visitors leave flowers, coins, and plastic vampire fangs. Some have scratched their names into the stone. There's a notebook tucked in a plastic box beside her grave, and people write to her in it.

And if you turn around, straight across the cemetery, you'll see it. The little stone crypt where she waited all that winter, while her neighbors decided what she was.

Lena wasn't the first girl in Exeter they blamed.

Nearly a hundred years earlier, around 1799, a farmer named Stukeley Tillinghast watched consumption take his children one after another. The town dug them up too. His daughter Sarah, it's said, was the one they decided was coming back.

Sarah Tillinghast is buried somewhere in a tiny family graveyard in the Exeter woods, behind an old stone wall. Nobody knows which of the graves is hers.

And across Rhode Island, in a cemetery in North Smithfield, an 1841 gravestone still warns of “consumption's vampire grasp.”

In this corner of New England, the dead were under suspicion for a very long time.

A family dying one by one. A father who didn't believe. A doctor holding the truth in his hands. And a town so afraid that it cut out a dead girl's heart anyway, and made her brother drink it.

There was no monster in Exeter. That's the most frightening part. Just fear, and grief, and ordinary neighbors who decided a 19-year-old girl was the thing in the dark.

If you ever stand at her grave, bring flowers.

And maybe glance back at the crypt on your way out.

Until Next Tide,

Hey Coastal

We've helped newsletter owners turn small lists into $2K-$10K/month, without quitting their job or getting on camera. See the exact system inside this free workshop, no experience required.

Save Your Free Seat