The White Doe of Roanoke Island

CBD is having a moment and CBD brands are everywhere right now. But with so many options, it can be tough to know what to look for – and which brands actually follow through on their claims.

That’s where CBDistillery sets itself apart. For the past decade, all of CBDistillery's products have been made with non-GMO, US-grown industrial hemp and with 100% clean ingredients – no corn syrup or artificial colors, flavors, preservatives or sweeteners.

They frequently introduce new and innovative products formulated to meet a variety of wellness needs and customer preferences. And every single batch of CBDistillery’s gummies, oil tinctures, topicals and softgels are tested by an independent, accredited lab to make sure what’s in the package matches what’s on the label.

Right now, CBDistillery is offering our readers a special deal: save 50% on orders of $75 or more with code NEWS50!

Try Trusted CBD

Hey Coastal,

You know the outline of this one already. English colonists vanish from Roanoke Island. One word, CROATOAN, carved into a post. No bodies, no answers, one of the oldest unsolved mysteries in American history.

This isn't that story. This is what people started telling each other once the real story refused to end, a tale of a doomed love triangle, a jealous curse, and a woman who turned into a white deer. And here's the part that actually surprised us while researching it: the "ancient legend" almost everyone repeats might not be ancient at all.

Virginia Dare was a real person. Born on Roanoke Island on August 18, 1587, she was the first child of English parentage born anywhere in the Americas. Nine days later, her grandfather, colony governor John White, sailed back to England to get more supplies. War with Spain kept him away for three years. When he finally returned in August 1590, on what would have been Virginia's third birthday, the entire colony was gone. No bodies. No signs of a struggle. Just the word CROATOAN carved into a post, and a mystery that's never been solved.

That much is documented history. Everything after it is folklore, and it's worth being honest about exactly where that line falls.

As the legend goes, Virginia didn't die with the rest of the colony. She survived, raised among a local tribe, and grew into a young woman courted by two suitors. One version names her rejected suitor as a jealous, powerful sorcerer, sometimes called Chico, who couldn't have her and cursed her out of spite, transforming her into a white doe. Other versions instead cast Wanchese, an actual historical Native leader who is documented to have traveled to England years earlier, as the hostile figure.

The suitor she loved, usually named Okisko, learns of the curse and gets a magical arrow, made from oyster shell or mother-of-pearl depending on who's telling it, meant to break the spell and restore her to human form. In some versions, he's the only hunter in the woods that day, and her death is a tragic accident. In others, a second hunter fires at the exact same moment with a cursed silver arrow meant to kill her outright. Either way, both arrows find their mark. The white doe falls. When Okisko reaches her, she's transformed back into Virginia Dare, dying in his arms.

It's genuinely one of the more beautiful, tragic pieces of American folklore we've come across. It's also, we should say plainly, not something anyone can verify happened, in any version.

Here's what we didn't expect going into this one. This legend gets marketed constantly as ancient Native American oral tradition, something passed down for centuries before it was ever written down. We went looking for the earliest version of it we could actually find and verify.

What we found was a book-length narrative poem called The White Doe: The Fate of Virginia Dare, published in 1901 by a writer named Sallie Southall Cotten. It's the earliest fully written, widely circulated version of this story we could locate, and its specific plot details, the named suitors, the dueling magic arrows, the exact death scene, closely match nearly every retelling published since.

Cotten was a white North Carolina author and clubwoman, writing more than three hundred years after the colonists disappeared. We could not find a single pre-1900s written account, from any source, confirming this specific story existed as genuine Native oral tradition before her. That doesn't prove it didn't. Oral traditions don't always leave paper trails, and it's entirely possible some version of this story was circulating locally before Cotten wrote hers down. But we also can't just repeat the "ancient Indian legend" label as settled fact when the actual documentary trail starts with a poem, published in 1901, by someone who wasn't Native at all.

We think that's worth knowing. A story doesn't have to be ancient to be meaningful. But it should be honest about what it actually is.

One small thing survived from Cotten's version that has nothing to do with curses or arrows. Cotten was also a real, documented advocate for North Carolina's scuppernong grape and wine industry, and she wrote a scuppernong vine growing from the ground where Virginia's blood fell into the poem's closing scene. It's a strange little fingerprint, proof that even a legend gets shaped by whoever happens to be holding the pen.

According to North Carolina's own state historical sources, yes, people have reported it. Hunters and residents on Roanoke Island described encounters with an unusually elusive white deer well into the twentieth century, always tied back to Virginia Dare. Here's the honest, unglamorous explanation that doesn't require any magic at all: piebald and leucistic deer, animals with a genetic condition that produces unusually pale or fully white coloring, are a real, if uncommon, occurrence in white-tailed deer populations exactly like the ones that live on Roanoke Island today. It's entirely possible that generations of hunters really have spotted a genuinely white deer out there, again and again, with a perfectly natural explanation waiting underneath the legend the whole time.

The Lost Colony, the outdoor symphonic drama telling the story of the Roanoke colonists, has run seasonally at Waterside Theatre on Roanoke Island since 1937, and it's widely considered the longest continuously running outdoor drama in the entire United States.

That's nearly ninety years of the same island telling and retelling the story of its own vanished colonists, night after night, summer after summer, to audiences who keep showing up. The White Doe legend and the outdoor drama grew up alongside each other, two different ways one small island has spent nearly a century trying to make sense of a mystery it never actually solved.

Virginia Dare's actual fate has never been found. What grew up in its place, a curse, a doomed love story, a woman who became a deer, isn't history. It's what people needed the silence to mean.

We can't tell you whether it's centuries old or barely over a hundred years young. We can tell you it's one of the strangest, most beautiful things ever built out of not knowing.

Until Next Tide,

Hey Coastal